The Decline of the UK's Graduate Wage Premium
Exploring the shrinking graduate wage premium in the UK and the need for improvement in the economy to support well-paid graduate jobs.
Video Summary
In recent years, the UK has witnessed a concerning trend in the shrinking graduate wage premium, where graduates are earning less compared to non-graduates. This stands in stark contrast to the US, where the value of degrees has been on the rise. The diminishing value of academic education in the UK is not solely attributed to an oversaturation of graduates in the job market. Rather, the crux of the issue lies in the lack of demand for graduate jobs and a misalignment in the types of graduates being produced, particularly in the fields of Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics (STEM).
The UK economy is in dire need of improvement to bolster the availability of well-paid graduate jobs and to enhance the overall graduate premium. As the landscape of work continues to evolve, it is imperative for the UK to focus on nurturing a workforce that is equipped with the skills and expertise demanded by the modern job market. By fostering a conducive environment for growth and innovation, the UK can pave the way for a resurgence in the value of academic qualifications and a resurgence in the graduate wage premium.
In conclusion, the challenges surrounding the UK's graduate wage premium necessitate a multifaceted approach that addresses both the supply and demand sides of the equation. By fostering a symbiotic relationship between educational institutions, industries, and policymakers, the UK can strive towards a future where graduates are not only abundant but also highly sought after in the job market. It is imperative for the UK to recalibrate its focus towards producing graduates that are not only well-educated but also well-equipped to thrive in a rapidly changing economic landscape.
Click on any timestamp in the keypoints section to jump directly to that moment in the video. Enhance your viewing experience with seamless navigation. Enjoy!
Keypoints
00:00:02
Government's Efforts to Increase University Education
Since 1999, the government has aimed to increase young people's access to University education. In 1999, Tony Blair's new labor government set a target to send half of young people to University, which was only achieved 20 years later in 2019.
00:00:22
Rationale Behind University Education Target
The target to increase University education was based on the belief that a more educated population leads to greater prosperity. Having a degree was seen as a pathway to better job opportunities and a higher quality of life.
00:00:46
Graduate Wage Premium
The concept of the graduate wage premium refers to the additional earnings per hour that graduates make compared to non-graduates. In the UK, the wage premium has been shrinking over the years, dropping below 40% by 2022.
00:01:25
Factors Influencing Graduate Wage Premium
Successive governments in the UK have encouraged more young people to pursue academic education, leading to an oversupply of graduates. This oversupply has contributed to the decline in the graduate wage premium.
00:02:09
Global Disparities in Graduate Wage Premium
While the UK has seen a decline in the graduate wage premium, the US has experienced an increase in the value of degrees. In cities like San Francisco and DC, graduates can earn nearly 70% more than non-graduates, compared to around 50% in 1997.
00:03:30
Student Debt Disparities
English graduates face significant debt upon graduation, with an average of nearly £60,000, higher than in the US, Australia, and Denmark. Despite higher debt levels, the US has seen a rise in the wage premium for graduates.
00:04:00
Reasons for Decline in Academic Education Value
In the UK, the decline in the value of academic education is attributed to an overabundance of Humanities degrees, leading to a shortage of technical skills. This has prompted a shift towards technical education to address the skills gap.
00:04:34
Comparison of Graduate Workforce
The share of the workforce aged between 25 and 59 with a bachelor's degree as the highest qualification is nearly identical in the UK at 27.8% and in the US at 27.4%. When adding Masters degrees, the figures get even closer, with 42% in the UK and 41.9% in the US. Despite this, American graduates earn more, indicating that the issue of the fallen graduate premium in the UK is not due to an oversupply of graduates but rather a lack of demand for graduate jobs.
00:05:09
Graduate Job Discrepancy
There is a significant disconnect in the UK between being a graduate and working in a graduate-level job. In regions like Yorkshire, the Humber, Scotland, the northeast of England, and the West Midlands, over a third of university graduates are working in non-graduate occupations. This trend is even more pronounced in the East Midlands and Wales, where the number exceeds 40%. Since the 2008 Global financial crisis, these numbers have been on the rise.
00:05:44
Economic Factors Affecting Graduate Employment
According to a working paper by Anna Stansbury of MIT and former UK Shadow Chancellor Ed Balls, the lack of businesses snapping up graduates in the north of England is attributed to two main economic problems: regional inequality with an overemphasis on London, Oxford, and Cambridge, and a relative shortage of STEM graduates. The UK economy's structural issues, including a lack of productivity and strength, hinder its ability to create well-paid jobs for the influx of graduates each year.
00:06:48
Solution to Graduate Employment Challenges
While the shortage of STEM graduates seems to be resolving itself as more students opt for STEM subjects, the broader UK economy needs improvement to raise the graduate premium to American levels. Enhancing the economy's strength and productivity is crucial to supporting the increasing number of graduates entering the workforce.
00:07:06
Media Coverage of UK Economy
The UK economy, particularly Chancellor Joy Hunt's plans, is extensively covered in the media. Reports indicate a mix of perspectives, with 25% of reporting from the left and 50% from the right. Varied headlines reflect contrasting views, such as rejecting corporate investment tax cuts permanently on the left and considering a major cut to inheritance tax on the right.
00:08:36
Ground News Platform
Ground News, developed by a former NASA engineer, offers readers a data-driven, objective way to consume news. The platform provides a breakdown of political bias, factuality, and source ownership, supported by ratings from three independent news monitoring organizations. Ground News helps users identify blind spots in news coverage and encourages critical thinking by presenting diverse perspectives. Viewers are encouraged to explore Ground News, with a special offer available exclusively through the provided link.