Comparative Review of Active Noise Cancelling Headphones: AirPods Max, Sony WH-1000XM5, and Bose QuietComfort Ultras
Explore a detailed comparison of the ANC performance of Apple AirPods Max, Sony WH-1000XM5, and Bose QuietComfort Ultras, highlighting their strengths and pricing.
Video Summary
In a recent review, the performance of active noise cancelling (ANC) technology was put to the test among three leading headphone models: the Apple AirPods Max, Sony WH-1000XM5, and Bose QuietComfort Ultras. Utilizing a binaural microphone for objective analysis, the speaker conducted a series of tests across four distinct sound levels: bass, midtones, high-pitch sounds, and pink noise. This comprehensive evaluation aimed to determine which model truly excelled in noise cancellation.
During the bass test, both the Apple AirPods Max and Bose QuietComfort Ultras demonstrated impressive capabilities, performing similarly and significantly better than the Sony WH-1000XM5, which lagged behind by over 10 dB. This initial finding set the stage for a deeper exploration into the ANC performance of these headphones.
In the midtone test, the Bose QuietComfort Ultras stood out as the clear winner, showcasing superior noise cancellation. The AirPods Max followed closely, while the Sony WH-1000XM5 struggled to keep pace, indicating a weaker performance in this frequency range. This disparity highlighted the strengths of the Bose model in handling midrange sounds effectively.
The high-pitch sound test revealed an interesting twist, as the Sony WH-1000XM5 emerged as the best performer in cancelling everyday sounds, such as the clicks of a keyboard. It achieved an impressive reduction of 27.6 dB, showcasing its ability to handle higher frequency noises that are often encountered in daily life.
Finally, the pink noise test, which assesses performance across the entire frequency spectrum, crowned the Bose QuietComfort Ultras as the overall champion. Their consistent performance across various sound levels solidified their reputation in the ANC category. Priced at $430, the Bose QuietComfort Ultras were deemed the best in class for active noise cancelling, followed by the Apple AirPods Max at $550 and the Sony WH-1000XM5 at $350.
In conclusion, while the review underscored the importance of ANC performance, it also emphasized that consumers should consider additional factors such as comfort, sound quality, and ecosystem integration when making their purchasing decisions. Each model has its strengths, and understanding these nuances can help buyers choose the right headphones for their needs.
Click on any timestamp in the keypoints section to jump directly to that moment in the video. Enhance your viewing experience with seamless navigation. Enjoy!
Keypoints
00:00:00
Introduction to Testing
The speaker, a tech reviewer, expresses enthusiasm for testing products, particularly focusing on the objective performance of active noise cancelling headphones. They introduce the use of a binaural microphone, the 3dio fs XLR, which mimics human hearing through prosthetic ears equipped with microphones, allowing for accurate noise cancellation testing.
Keypoint ads
00:01:04
Base Test Results
In the first test, the speaker evaluates the headphones' performance against airplane noise, using a baseline recording to illustrate the noise levels. The AirPods Max demonstrate superior noise cancellation, followed closely by the Bose QuietComfort Ultras, while the Sony XM5s lag behind with a significant difference of over 10 dB compared to the Bose. The speaker notes a marked improvement in noise cancellation technology over the past five years, referencing their older Bose 700s.
Keypoint ads
00:03:05
Midtone Test Introduction
Transitioning to the second level of testing, the speaker introduces a midtone test featuring human chatter. This test aims to further assess the headphones' noise cancelling capabilities in a different frequency range, setting the stage for a comparative analysis of the headphones' performance.
Keypoint ads
00:03:16
Noise Cancellation Test
The speaker conducts a noise cancellation test using various headphones, focusing on the mid-range frequencies typical of human voices. The test limits the frequency range from 150 Hz to 5,000 Hz to analyze performance against common background noises like café chatter and HVAC systems. The AirPods Max (red) and Bose QuietComfort Ultras (blue) outperform the Sony XM5 (green) in the lower mids, while the Sony XM5 begins to excel in the upper mids, indicating a nuanced performance across different frequency ranges.
Keypoint ads
00:04:53
High-Pitch Sound Test
The next phase involves a high-pitch sound test, which is less relevant to everyday noise cancellation scenarios. The frequency range is set from 3,000 Hz to 20,000 Hz. The speaker notes that while performance is similar across all headphones in the 7,000 Hz to 20,000 Hz range, the Sony XM5 shows superior performance in the 2,000 Hz to 8,000 Hz range, which includes more common sounds like keyboard and mouse clicks. This observation is supported by the speaker's personal experience, confirming that the Sony headphones provide the best noise isolation in a typical office environment.
Keypoint ads
00:06:36
Noise Cancellation Performance
The performance of various headphones in noise cancellation was tested, revealing that Sony headphones reduced noise by 27.6 dB, followed by Apple AirPods, Bose Ultras, and Bose 700s. The test included a level four stress test using pink noise, which is not commonly encountered in daily life. The speaker speculated that this test could indicate the load capacity of the drivers and the processing power of the headphones.
Keypoint ads
00:07:55
Headphone Frequency Response
During the pink noise test, it was observed that the AirPods and Bose headphones dominated the bass and midrange frequencies, while the Sony headphones lagged behind. As the frequency increased into the upper mids and treble, the AirPods Max did not perform as well, with Sony headphones catching up. Ultimately, the Bose QuietComfort Ultras emerged as the clear winner, demonstrating consistent performance across the entire frequency spectrum with a baseline recording of 53.9 dB.
Keypoint ads
00:08:41
Overall Winner and Considerations
The Bose QuietComfort Ultras were declared the overall winner in noise cancellation, excelling in nearly every category. Priced at $430, they were compared to the $350 Sony headphones and the $550 AirPods Max. The speaker emphasized that while all three headphones performed well in noise cancellation, factors such as comfort, sound quality, and ecosystem compatibility should also be considered when choosing between them.
Keypoint ads
00:09:11
Future Testing and Engagement
The speaker expressed enthusiasm for conducting future tests on upcoming headphones and encouraged viewers to subscribe for more content. They invited comments from viewers regarding their favorite headphones and thoughts on the test results, indicating a desire for community engagement.
Keypoint ads